SB 1489: Recovering the cost of protecting Californians
A core part of the Attorney General’s responsibility is to prosecute “public rights” cases, such as environmental, consumer fraud, and civil rights. In 2004 the Legislature gave the A.G. the authority to recover court costs when they prevail in a case—the same authority enjoyed by private attorneys and a number of state Attorneys General. When a subsequent court ruling invalidated the authority on an unrelated technicality, the Legislature passed SB 1489 (Ducheny) to clarify and affirm the A.G.’s authority to recover costs for these important “public rights” cases.
How did your elected official vote?
| Senator | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Richard Alarcón | D |
Good |
| Elaine Alquist | D |
Good |
| Roy Ashburn | R |
Bad |
| Jim Battin | R |
Bad |
| Debra Bowen | D |
Good |
| Gil Cedillo | D |
Bad |
| Wesley Chesbro | D |
Good |
| Dave Cox | R |
Bad |
| Jeff Denham | R |
Bad |
| Denise Ducheny | D |
Good |
| Joe Dunn | D |
Good |
| Bob Dutton | R |
Bad |
| Martha Escutia | D |
Good |
| Liz Figueroa | D |
Good |
| Dean Florez | D |
Bad |
| Tom Harman | R |
Bad |
| Dennis Hollingsworth | R |
Bad |
| Christine Kehoe | D |
Good |
| Sheila Kuehl | D |
Good |
| Alan Lowenthal | D |
Good |
| Michael Machado | D |
Good |
| Abel Maldonado | R |
Bad |
| Bob Margett | R |
Bad |
| Tom McClintock | R |
Bad |
| Carole Migden | D |
Good |
| Bill Morrow | R |
Bad |
| Kevin Murray | D |
Good |
| Deborah Ortiz | D |
Bad |
| Don Perata | D |
Good |
| Chuck Poochigian | R |
Bad |
| Gloria Romero | D |
Good |
| George Runner | R |
Bad |
| Jack Scott | D |
Good |
| Joe Simitian | D |
Good |
| Nell Soto | D |
Good |
| Jackie Speier | D |
Good |
| Tom Torlakson | D |
Good |
| Edward Vincent | D |
Good |
Pro-Environmental Action
Anti-Environmental Action
Not Voting
Excused
Pro-Environmental Action
Anti-Environmental Action
Not Voting
Excused
Pro-Environmental Action
Anti-Environmental Action
Not Voting
Excused
Know Your Legislators »
Who represents you in the Assembly & State Senate? Find out how they voted on key environmental proposals.
Stay Connected »
Keep up with the latest from CLCV: environmental news, urgent action alerts, and more.
Donate »
Your support for CLCV helps maintain California's standing as the nation's environmental leader.
2011 California Environmental Scorecard
How did your legislators perform in Sacramento—and how did Jerry Brown do in his return to the governor's office?
Find out in CLCV's 2011 California Environmental Scorecard.
Now that you know the score, take action: Tell your legislators you know the score!

Donate