AB 1998: Sacking the bag
Even with support from a diverse coalition ranging from retailers, environmental groups, grocers, unions, state and local government, celebrities, labor groups, and reusable bag manufacturers, the State Senate failed to pass the widely touted AB 1998 (Brownley). A strongly mounted attack by the American Chemistry Council and a growing "Mod Dem Caucus" in the Senate dashed the hopes of many Californians to be the first state in the Union to ban the "urban tumbleweed" and chronic ocean polluter: the single- use plastic bag. As Mexico City, American Samoa and even provinces in China are added to the list of countries and regions that have already said no to plastic bags, California still looks for ways to get a handle on this environmental blight.
How did your elected official vote?
| Senator | Party | Vote |
|---|---|---|
| Sam Aanestad | R |
Bad |
| Elaine Alquist | D |
Good |
| Roy Ashburn | R |
Bad |
| Sam Blakeslee | R |
Not Voting |
| Ron Calderon | D |
Bad |
| Gil Cedillo | D |
Good |
| Dave Cogdill | R |
Bad |
| Ellen Corbett | D |
Good |
| Lou Correa | D |
Bad |
| Jeff Denham | R |
Bad |
| Mark DeSaulnier | D |
Good |
| Denise Ducheny | D |
Bad |
| Bob Dutton | R |
Bad |
| Bill Emmerson | R |
Bad |
| Dean Florez | D |
Bad |
| Loni Hancock | D |
Good |
| Tom Harman | R |
Bad |
| Dennis Hollingsworth | R |
Bad |
| Bob Huff | R |
Bad |
| Christine Kehoe | D |
Good |
| Mark Leno | D |
Good |
| Carol Liu | D |
Good |
| Alan Lowenthal | D |
Good |
| Gloria Negrete McLeod | D |
Bad |
| Jenny Oropeza | D |
Excused |
| Alex Padilla | D |
Good |
| Fran Pavley | D |
Good |
| Curren Price | D |
Bad |
| Gloria Romero | D |
Bad |
| George Runner | R |
Bad |
| Joe Simitian | D |
Good |
| Darrell Steinberg | D |
Good |
| Tony Strickland | R |
Not Voting |
| Mimi Walters | R |
Bad |
| Pat Wiggins | D |
Excused |
| Lois Wolk | D |
Bad |
| Rod Wright | D |
Bad |
| Mark Wyland | R |
Bad |
| Leland Yee | D |
Good |
Pro-Environmental Action
Anti-Environmental Action
Not Voting
Excused
Pro-Environmental Action
Anti-Environmental Action
Not Voting
Excused
There are no Governor votes for this bill.
Know Your Legislators »
Who represents you in the Assembly & State Senate? Find out how they voted on key environmental proposals.
Stay Connected »
Keep up with the latest from CLCV: environmental news, urgent action alerts, and more.
Donate »
Your support for CLCV helps maintain California's standing as the nation's environmental leader.
2011 California Environmental Scorecard
How did your legislators perform in Sacramento—and how did Jerry Brown do in his return to the governor's office?
Find out in CLCV's 2011 California Environmental Scorecard.
Now that you know the score, take action: Tell your legislators you know the score!

Donate